God’s Free Choice of Jacob over Esau

By the example of Esau and Jacob, Paul proves that the rejection of the Jews does not call God’s faithfulness into question, since he has a sovereign right to choose, or call, as he pleases. The children, who stood for nations, were not yet born, so they could neither earn God’s preference nor deserve to be left out of his covenant. Such distinctions, then, plainly depend on God’s free choice, and illustrate God’s purpose in election.

AD 58

Literal Standard Version (LSV)

Romans 9:10–13

10 And not only [so], but also Rebecca, having conceived by one—our father Isaac 11 (for they being not yet born, neither having done anything good or evil, that the purpose of God, according to [divine] selection, might remain; not of works, but of Him who is calling), 12 it was said to her, “The greater will serve the less”; 13 according as it has been written: “Jacob I loved, and Esau I hated.”

God’s Choice of Nations Is Just

Paul continues his argument by affirming that God’s free choice, as it concerns nations, is fully consistent with his justice, since he has a sovereign right to give his freely willed blessings and mercies as he pleases. This is shown in the Israelites of old, whose sins as a nation God, of his own free mercy, pardoned after they had worshiped the golden calf (Exodus 33:9), as he declared to Moses. For no one can ever earn the mercy of God or claim it as a right. Had it pleased God, the Israelites after their apostasy might have been kept on as a nation, as the Egyptians were, for the purpose of showing in their destruction and punishment the almighty power of God and his hatred of sin. Paul then hints at the rejection of the Jews by asserting that the same free gift of mercy is still given, and that the same punishment, as an example, will fall on those who go on and harden themselves in sin, resisting, as the Egyptians did, the evidence that was graciously given them.

Romans 9:14–18

14 What, then, will we say? Unrighteousness [is] with God? Let it not be! 15 For to Moses He says, “I will do kindness to whom I do kindness, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion”;

16 so then—not of him who is willing, nor of him who is running, but of God who is doing kindness; 17 for the Writing says to Pharaoh, “For this very thing I raised you up, that I might show in you My power, and that My Name might be declared in all the land”; 18 so then, to whom He wills, He does kindness, and to whom He wills, He hardens.

Like a Potter, God Exalts and Rejects Nations

Paul here brings in a Jew who says, “Then why does God still find fault? For who can resist his will?”, if God is determined to destroy nations. Paul answers, “But who are you, O man, to talk back to God?” He defends the justice of God’s dealings with the Jews and Gentiles, and shows his absolute power over nations, raising up one and rejecting another, by referring to Jeremiah’s image of the potter. He then applies the image more directly to the present state of the Jews and the Gentiles. Like the Egyptians, after repeated proofs of God’s patience, the Jews became vessels of wrath prepared for destruction, making known the power of God for salvation. By their means the believing Gentiles were prepared for the glory of being admitted into the visible church of God, and with the believing Jews were called to be God’s people and the vessels of his mercy. Their own ancient prophets foretold and taught the same truths.

Romans 9:19–29

19 You will say, then, to me, “Why does He yet find fault? For who has resisted His counsel?” 20 No, but, O man, who are you that are answering again to God? Will the thing formed say to Him who formed [it], Why did you make me thus? 21 Does the potter not have authority over the clay, out of the same lump to make one vessel to honor and one to dishonor?

22 And if God, willing to show the wrath and to make known His power, endured, in much long suffering, vessels of wrath fitted for destruction, 23 and that He might make known the riches of His glory on vessels of kindness, that He before prepared for glory, whom also He called—us— 24 not only out of Jews, but also out of nations, 25 as also in Hosea He says, “I will call what [is] not My people—My people; and her not beloved—Beloved, 26 and it will be—in the place where it was said to them, You [are] not My people; there they will be called sons of the living God.”

27 And Isaiah cries concerning Israel, “If the number of the sons of Israel may be as the sand of the sea, the remnant will be saved;

28 for a matter He is finishing, and is cutting short in righteousness, because a matter cut short will the LORD do on the land.”

29 And according as Isaiah says before, “Except the LORD of Hosts left to us a seed, we had become as Sodom, and we had been made like Gomorrah.”

Israel Stumbled for Lack of Faith

Having clearly set out the rejection of the Jews and shown it to agree with God’s truth and justice, Paul brings in a Jew asking whether the Gentiles, who did not follow the rule of righteousness given in the Law of Moses, have now gained the righteousness of faith and the privileges of God’s chosen people, while the Jews, who followed the righteousness of the Law, have not gained righteousness by faith in the gospel. Paul declares that the cause of their rejection was their lack of faith and their reliance on the works of the Law, which led them to look for justification from keeping its rites, as one of their own prophets had foretold. Paul repeats his deep desire that the Jews would believe and be saved. He grants their zeal for the glory of the Law, but it was without knowledge of the purpose and end of its rites. Their ignorance of God’s plan of salvation through faith made them try to set up their own way of justification, through the sacrifices and ceremonies of the Law, and kept them from submitting to the righteousness of faith, which God requires as the only means of salvation.

Romans 9:30–10:3

30 What, then, will we say? That nations who are not pursuing righteousness attained to righteousness, and righteousness that [is] of faith, 31 and Israel, pursuing a law of righteousness, did not arrive at a law of righteousness; 32 why? Because—not by faith, but as by works of law; for they stumbled at the stone of stumbling, 33 according as it has been written: “Behold, I place in Zion a stone of stumbling and a rock of offense; and everyone who is believing thereon will not be ashamed.”

10:1 Brothers, the pleasure indeed of my heart, and my supplication that [is] to God for Israel, is—for salvation; 2 for I bear them testimony that they have a zeal of God, but not according to knowledge, 3 for not knowing the righteousness of God, and seeking to establish their own righteousness, they did not submit to the righteousness of God.

Christ Is the End of the Law

To convince the Jews of their error about justification by their Law, Paul describes the kind of righteousness the Law requires and the kind the gospel requires. He affirms that Christ himself was the end, or the perfection, of the Law, the great object of all its rites and sacrifices. Moses has declared that no one can be justified by the Law, because no one could live up to its commands. But the law, or principle, of faith, as Moses describes it (Deuteronomy 30:11–14), does not require the signs from heaven that the Jews demanded, that Christ should come down from heaven again and rise again from the dead, for the word was always near them, and they were given power to fulfill it. So it was with the gospel: it requires us to confess our faith in Jesus Christ and to be inwardly convinced of the truth of his resurrection, producing a righteous life. Scripture has declared that no one will be put to shame or disappointed in their trust, and that the plan of redemption reaches to all, both Jew and Gentile, for all who believe in Christ and call on him will be saved.

Romans 10:4–13

4 For Christ is an end of law for righteousness to everyone who is believing, 5 for Moses describes the righteousness that [is] of the Law, that, “The man who did them will live in them,” 6 and the righteousness of faith thus speaks: “You may not say in your heart, Who will go up to Heaven?” (that is, to bring Christ down) 7 or, “Who will go down to the abyss?” (that is, to bring up Christ out of the dead).

8 But what does it say? “The saying is near you—in your mouth, and in your heart”: that is, the saying of the faith that we preach; 9 that if you may confess with your mouth that Jesus [is] LORD, and may believe in your heart that God raised Him out of the dead, you will be saved, 10 for with the heart [one] believes to righteousness, and with the mouth is confession made to salvation;

11 for the Writing says, “Everyone who is believing on Him will not be ashamed,” 12 for there is no difference between Jew and Greek, for the same Lord of all [is] rich to all those calling on Him, 13 for “Everyone who, if he may have called on the Name of the LORD, will be saved.”

Paul Defends His Divine Mission to the Gentiles

From the prophecies of the New Testament, now being fulfilled, Paul is led to defend his divine mission and that of the other apostles. He asks how these prophecies, which foretold the acceptance of the Gentiles, could be fulfilled, for without the gospel there could be no salvation, and without preachers it could not have been proclaimed. As a Jew, he asserts that his prejudices would have kept him from taking the gospel to the Gentiles unless he had been divinely appointed to do so. He shows, from the prophecy of Isaiah, their great success and the glad welcome given to the messengers of salvation.

Romans 10:14–15

14 How then will they call on [Him] in whom they did not believe? And how will they believe [on Him] of whom they did not hear? And how will they hear apart from one preaching? 15 And how will they preach, if they may not be sent? According as it has been written: “How beautiful the feet of those proclaiming good tidings of peace, of those proclaiming good tidings of the good things!”

The Prophets Foretold Israel’s Unbelief

Here the Jew is imagined objecting that a divine commission would have met with full success, whereas many did not obey the faith of the gospel. Paul replies that the Spirit of God had already foretold this outcome in the case of the Jews themselves. He asserts that faith is produced by means of preaching and hearing, by the command of God himself, and asks whether they have not all heard the good news of salvation. The apostles have preached the gospel to the Jew as well as the Gentile, fulfilling the words of the psalmist, which he applied to the teaching of the heavenly bodies that reaches everywhere. Paul asks further whether Israel did not know that the gospel was to be preached to the Gentiles, since their prophets had so plainly foretold the calling of the Gentiles and their joyful welcome of the gospel, as well as the rejection of the Jews.

Romans 10:16–21

16 But they were not all obedient to the good tidings, for Isaiah says, “LORD, who gave credence to our report?” 17 So then faith [is] by a report, and the report through a saying of God, 18 but I say, did they not hear? Yes, indeed, “their voice went forth to all the earth, and their sayings to the ends of the habitable world.”

19 But I say, did Israel not know? First Moses says, “I will provoke you to jealousy by [that which is] not a nation,

By an unintelligent nation I will anger you,”

20 and Isaiah is very bold and says, “I was found by those not seeking Me; I became visible to those not inquiring after Me”;

21 and to Israel He says, “All the day I stretched out My hands to a people unbelieving and contradicting.”

God Has Not Wholly Rejected His People

Having declared so plainly the rejection of the Jews as a nation, Paul comforts them with the assurance that God has not wholly cast away his chosen people. For, as in the days of Elijah, there will still remain a remnant of converted Jews who, with the believing Gentiles, are chosen through faith to be God’s people, not by good works but by the grace and favor of God alone.

Romans 11:1–6

1 I say then, did God cast away His people? Let it not be! For I am also an Israelite, of the seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin: 2 God did not cast away His people whom He knew before; have you not known—in Elijah—what the Writing says? How he pleads with God concerning Israel, saying, 3 “LORD, they killed Your prophets, and they dug down Your altars, and I was left alone, and they seek my life”;

4 but what does the divine answer say to him? “I left to Myself seven thousand men who did not bow a knee to Ba‘al.”

5 So then also in the present time there has been a remnant according to the [divine] selection of grace; 6 and if by grace, no longer of works, otherwise grace becomes no longer grace; and if of works, it is no longer grace, otherwise work is no longer work.